What type of roofing is typically less durable compared to rigid roofing materials?

Shingle roofing is typically considered less durable compared to rigid roofing materials like metal roofing or clay tiles. This is primarily due to the composition and structure of shingles, which are often made from asphalt or fiberglass. While they are designed for effective water shedding and can withstand various weather conditions, they have a shorter lifespan and are more prone to wear and damage from harsh environmental elements such as strong winds, hail, or extreme heat.

In contrast, rigid roofing materials such as metal roofing or clay tiles offer greater resistance to these conditions. Metal roofing is especially known for its longevity and ability to endure severe weather, while clay tiles have a lifespan that can exceed 50 years when properly maintained. Wood shakes can also have durability concerns, especially in terms of moisture retention and susceptibility to rot, but they generally do not match the performance characteristics of rigid materials. This makes shingle roofing the option that aligns with the description of being less durable.